Wind Turbine Controller Review: Why I Avoid Cheap Hybrid MPPTs

This article details a frustrating experience with a cheap, Chinese-made hybrid MPPT wind turbine controller. The author purchased a 2000-watt controller, but testing revealed a drastically lower real-world capacity, struggling to handle even 400 watts before activating an unadjustable 10-minute brake. This rendered the controller unusable with the author's 1500-watt turbine due to constant interruptions. Further issues included unreliable overload protection and a complete lack of crucial information from the manufacturer and seller.The failure of the commercially available controller led the author to build a custom solution. This involved repurposing components from the faulty unit and incorporating a proven MPPT solar charge controller, a three-phase rectifier, and a custom braking system utilizing an M260-9 circuit board. The resulting system effectively manages power from both solar panels and the wind turbine, providing superior reliability and protection compared to the initial disappointing purchase. This project highlights the pitfalls of relying on inexpensive, untested electronics for critical applications.

Read more: InnerVenue's Forever Battery: Revolutionizing Renewable Energy Storage

A Disappointing Hybrid MPPT Controller

I recently purchased a Chinese-made wind solar hybrid MPPT controller advertised as a 2000-watt unit compatible with 12V and 24V batteries. However, my testing revealed a significant discrepancy between the advertised power handling capacity and its real-world performance. The controller struggled to manage even 400 watts of power.

The advertised Chinese MPPT wind solar hybrid controller box
The advertised Chinese MPPT wind solar hybrid controller box

After exceeding 400 watts, the controller inexplicably activates a 10-minute brake. This is a non-adjustable default setting, making it wholly unsuitable for larger wind turbines that frequently surpass this threshold. For my 1500-watt turbine, this braking mechanism resulted in continuous interruptions, rendering the controller practically useless.

Screenshot showing the controller's brake activation
Screenshot showing the controller's brake activation

Overload Protection and Misleading Specifications

The controller was also advertised with robust overload protection. However, during strong winds, the system still triggered overload protection, contradicting the manufacturer's claims. The advertised 2000-watt maximum wind power capacity proved entirely false. Furthermore, crucial information such as output current was absent from the product documentation.

Screenshot highlighting the misleading overload protection claims
Screenshot highlighting the misleading overload protection claims

The seller's lack of responsiveness and failure to provide a datasheet or any troubleshooting assistance exacerbated the issue. This overall experience prompted a negative review, and ultimately, a decision to build a custom solution.

The controller's false 2000-watt claim
The controller's false 2000-watt claim

Building a Custom Wind Turbine Controller

Instead of relying on the faulty controller, I decided to build my own using a proven MPPT solar charge controller as a base. This required addressing the difference between DC input voltage used by the solar charger and the three-phase AC power output of a wind turbine.

The solar charge controller used as a base
The solar charge controller used as a base

This involved incorporating a three-phase full-bridge rectifier (salvaged from the original controller) to convert the AC power to DC. A crucial component of this new controller was an automatic braking system to protect the turbine from damage caused by overspeeding when the battery is full.

The salvaged three-phase full-bridge rectifier
The salvaged three-phase full-bridge rectifier

Braking System and Final Setup

For the braking system, an M260-9 circuit board was utilized. This board continuously monitors battery voltage, activating a relay when a pre-set upper voltage threshold (battery full) is reached. The relay connects a high-power resistor, which acts as an electromagnetic brake for the wind turbine. A lower voltage threshold triggers the relay to disconnect the load when charging is complete.

The M260-9 circuit board used for braking
The M260-9 circuit board used for braking

The final setup includes two controllers (one for solar panels and one for wind turbine), a modified relay, and a low-pass filter to smooth out the DC power supply. The system efficiently manages power from both solar panels and the wind turbine while protecting the battery and the turbine itself.

Diagram of the final setup
Diagram of the final setup

Conclusion: A Waste of Money

The initial Chinese-made MPPT controller was a significant disappointment, severely underperforming and lacking essential features. Its unreliable brake mechanism and false advertising regarding power handling and overload protection made it a complete waste of money. The custom-built controller, however, successfully addresses all these shortcomings, demonstrating a far superior solution.

A shot emphasizing the warning not to buy the faulty controller
A shot emphasizing the warning not to buy the faulty controller

While the initial purchase was costly, building a custom controller ultimately proved more effective and reliable. The lessons learned highlight the importance of rigorous testing and realistic expectations when purchasing budget electronics, particularly for critical applications like wind turbine control.

The final setup of the custom controller
The final setup of the custom controller